Friday, March 30, 2018 – In defense of our right to self-government, please contact the Wisconsin Elections Commission in the next few days to tell them: Include routine election auditing in Wisconsin’s application for federal election-security funding.
Chances like this don’t come along very often. Congress sits on its hands for years, ignores problems, messes around, and then–when an issue is hot–throws some money at the states and says “Spend it quick!”
When that happens, states need to be able to grab the money and spend it on something worthwhile.
That is just what has happened with election security. Voters have been warning, shouting, complaining, and worrying for years about the dangers of poorly managed election technology, and then all of a sudden Congress awoke and leapt out of bed. (Thank you, Vladimir!) Last Friday, Congress passed a federal budget bill that includes $380 million for grants to the states for improving election security.*
Just short of $7 million of that is earmarked for Wisconsin–pending the Wisconsin Elections Commission’s submission of a plan for spending it.
Thirteen states should definitely spend their money to replace unauditable voting machines–the kind that don’t use or create a paper record of each ballot. But that’s not Wisconsin’s problem. Paperless vote-counting computers have always been illegal here.
Wisconsin’s big election-security hole–where we lag most other states–is not that our elections are unauditable. Wisconsin elections are simply unaudited.
Wisconsin is in relatively good shape on most other aspects of election security. The WEC has done a good job with those systems they control, which are the voter-registration system and the ‘canvass reporting system,’ the automated system that counties use to report results they have already counted and certified. In addition to having respectable security, both these systems also have effective backup in case of manipulation or failure. With same-day registration at the polls, hackers have to ask themselves how much effort they are going to waste deleting Wisconsin voters’ registrations when we will be able immediately to vote anyway, with only about five minutes’ re-registration inconvenience. And the canvass reporting system kicks in only after our votes have already been counted in the polling places and municipal clerks’ offices. Any hacking of that would be easily detectable and reversible, even without a serious audit effort.
But Wisconsin has no more security for our voting machines than any other state that uses paper ballots, and a paper trail is merely decorative if the ballots are sealed on Election Night and never seen again.
Our elections’ biggest unprotected vulnerability is that our county boards of canvass make a habit of declaring election results final without lifting a finger to check to see whether the vote-counting computers counted our votes correctly. That practice is justifiably illegal in 25 states (26 if you count D.C.) and contrary to every national election authority’s recommendation.
The practical solution: Wisconsin law provides county election officials with paper ballots and allows them to check accuracy before they certify, but they choose not to. The problem isn’t time or money. Wisconsin’s county clerks have as much time for the canvass as their counterparts in states that do audit, and modern election-audit methods are so efficient they could almost be funded from petty cash.
So we can only guess why our county officials continue to force us to trust our franchise to unaudited computer output–something they wouldn’t tolerate for a millisecond from their banks and ATMs. My best guess is that they’ve been allowed to ignore that basic managerial responsibility for so long that they fear they will find a host of problems when they start to look. Look at the panic this county official exhibited as she refused an observer’s request for verification during the 2016 recount. That level of distress looks to me like she knew the machines’ unreliability would be revealed if she allowed verification, so she refused to hand count “even five ballots.” And she was right: the machines were, in fact, miscounting and were later decertified by the Wisconsin Elections Commission.
What voters need to do:
Contact the WEC and tell them that you want them to include funding for routine audits during the county canvass in Wisconsin’s federal grant application. WEC staff are up to date on national election-administration trends, and I believe they understand the need for, and practicality of, routine election audits. In addition, I sense that WEC Commissioners are favorably disposed to effective election audits and will do the right thing if enough citizens express interest and support.
- Tweet to @WI_Elections to say that you want to see county election audits in the application for federal funding;
- Email Chair Mark Thomsen and Administrator Meagan Wolfe at email@example.com.
- Snail-mail them at Wisconsin Elections Commission, P.O. Box 7984, Madison, Wisconsin 53707-7984, with copies to U.S. Election Assistance Commission, 1335 East West Highway, Suite 4300, Silver Spring, MD 20910, and to Jill Lau, Chair, Wisconsin County Clerks Association, 421 Nebraska St, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin 54235.
If you want to do more, you can use these web-contact forms to tell Senator Baldwin, Senator Johnson, and the US Election Assistance Commission that they, too, should encourage the WEC to seek funds for election auditing in Wisconsin.
Also, please, tell other voters about this so that they, too, can weigh in for election audits. The WEC hardly ever gets any citizen input on election security issues, and they will definitely sit up and take notice if they get a lot now. So go for it!
* It would be unfair to accuse every member of Congress of inaction. Wisconsin’s very own Mark Pocan introduced an excellent elections-security bill, the Secure America’s Future Elections (SAFE) Act a year ago. As other representatives wake up to the issue, it’s still collecting new co-sponsors. If you live outside Wisconsin’s Second Congressional District, contact your congressperson today and ask them to sign on. If you live in Rep. Pocan’s district, tell him “Thank you!”